BASIC Comment
Plotting to mine uranium in Africa?
23 August 2006
Back to the BASIC Comment
index
The Sunday Times' report on 'Iran's plot to
mine uranium in Africa' last week plays upon people’s understandable
fears over Iran’s nuclear development. The central claim,
that Iran is importing large consignments of 'bomb-making'
uranium from the Lubumbashi mines in the Congo, is reminiscent
of discredited reports that Saddam sought to buy uranium from
Niger.
'Bomb-making uranium' does not come neatly packaged
out of mines. The Lubumbashi mine, if it were producing at
all, would provide raw uranium ore. This would have to be
converted and enriched before it could be used for bombs.
To date, Iran is some way off from being able to do this adequately
for weapons purposes. Not only this, but the mine has not
been active since 1961. Any illicit mining would involve enormous
quantities of extracted material, and a milling process nearby
involving heavy plant and machinery, and 'tailings' (waste
products from the milling process) that would be impossible
to hide either from the ground or from satellite.
Iran has around 12,000 tons of its own deposits
of natural uranium (of which well over 1,000 tons is easily
recoverable). It makes no sense to smuggle for bomb purposes
large quantities of processed yellowcake across numerous borders
and risk detection in the age of the Proliferation Security
Initiative when it could secretly open its own mine within
Iran or divert material from existing mines. If Iran were
to import natural uranium it would be to supply a uranium-intensive
nuclear power programme for the longer term, as its domestic
supplies would last around 12 years. As the US State Department
repeatedly points out, it would take Iran much more uranium
to fuel its planned seven power stations than it would to
build a modest nuclear arsenal.
Stories such as this from the Sunday Times appear
more intended to stoke up support for muscular action in an
already tense stand-off than to shed light on the complex
situation.
|
Iran's plot to mine uranium
in Africa
By Jon Swain, David Leppard and Brian Johnson-Thomas
The
Sunday Times, 6 August 2006
IRAN is seeking to import large consignments of bomb-making
uranium from the African mining area that produced the Hiroshima
bomb, an investigation has revealed.
A United Nations report, dated July 18, said there
was “no doubt” that a huge shipment of smuggled uranium 238, uncovered
by customs officials in Tanzania, was transported from the Lubumbashi
mines in the Congo.
Tanzanian customs officials told The Sunday Times
it was destined for the Iranian port of Bandar Abbas, and was stopped
on October 22 last year during a routine check.
The disclosure will heighten western fears about the
extent of Iran’s presumed nuclear weapons programme and the strategic
implications of Iran’s continuing support for Hezbollah during the
war with Israel.
It has also emerged that terror cells backed by Iran
may be prepared to mount attacks against nuclear power plants in
Britain. Intelligence circulating in Whitehall suggests that sleeper
cells linked to Tehran have been conducting reconnaissance at some
nuclear sites in preparation for a possible attack.
The parliamentary intelligence and security committee
has reported that Iran represented one of the three biggest security
threats to Britain. The UN security council has given Iran until
the end of this month to halt its uranium enrichment activities.
The UN has threatened sanctions if Tehran fails to do so.
A senior Tanzanian customs official said the illicit
uranium shipment was found hidden in a consignment of coltan, a
rare mineral used to make chips in mobile telephones. The shipment
was destined for smelting in the former Soviet republic of Kazakhstan,
delivered via Bandar Abbas, Iran’s biggest port.
“There were several containers due to be shipped and
they were all routinely scanned with a Geiger counter,” the official
said.
“This one was very radioactive. When we opened the
container it was full of drums of coltan. Each drum contains about
50kg of ore. When the first and second rows were removed,the ones
after that were found to be drums of uranium.”
In a nuclear reactor, uranium 238 can be used to breed
plutonium used in nuclear weapons.
The customs officer, who spoke to The Sunday Times
on condition he was not named, added: “The container was put in
a secure part of the port and it was later taken away, by the Americans,
I think, or at least with their help. We have all been told not
to talk to anyone about this.”
The report by the UN investigation team was submitted
to the chairman of the UN sanctions committee, Oswaldo de Rivero,
at the end of July and will be considered soon by the security council.
It states that Tanzania provided “limited data” on
three other shipments of radioactive materials seized in Dar es
Salaam over the past 10 years.
The experts said: “In reference to the last shipment
from October 2005, the Tanzanian government left no doubt that the
uranium was transported from Lubumbashi by road through Zambia to
the united republic of Tanzania.”
Lubumbashi is the capital of mineral-rich Katanga
province, home of the Shinkolobwe uranium mine that produced material
for the two atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August
1945.
The mine has officially been closed since 1961, before
the country’s independence from Belgium, but the UN investigators
have told the security council that they found evidence of illegal
mining still going on at the site.
In 1999 there were reports that the Congolese authorities
had tried to re-open the mine with the help of North Korea. In recent
years miners are said to have broken open the lids and extracted
ore from the shafts, while police and local authorities turned a
blind eye.
In June a parliamentary committee warned that Britain
could be attacked by Iranian terrorists if tensions increased.
A source with access to current MI5 assessments said:
“There is great concern about Iranian sleeper cells inside this
country. The intelligence services are taking this threat very seriously.”
|